1993-1994 Harry Singer Foundation National Essay Contest

Responsibility, Who Has It and Who Doesn't and What That Means For The Nation
Teacher: Jane Susan J. Long

bd06379_.wmf (5548 bytes)

Niantic High School, Niantic, Illinois

bd07220_.wmf (15782 bytes)1st Michael J. Pyle  bd07220_.wmf (15782 bytes)2nd Tom Moore  bd07217_.wmf (15136 bytes)3rd Alicia Dothager

 

In the excerpt that follows Quentin presents a farfetched lawsuit turning on cause and effect:

"The acquittal of Lorena Bobbitt...is a major victory for the attitude that everyone has an excuse. During the L.A. riots...if someone saw something they wanted they just took it. This action has been justified through the excuse that these people have been oppressed for so long that something was bound to happen." 
Tom Moore, Niantic-Harristown High School, Niantic, Illinois

"A boy recently sued a candy company that has a foil wrapper on its candy because they failed to state "remove foil before eating," After eating several of these candies, the boy suffered an intestinal blockage and had to be taken to the hospital. All you have to do is use common sense and you should know to unwrap candy first. This is very irresponsible on the part of the parents for letting the boy eat them with the wrapper on and I personally would feel pretty stupid suing someone because I ate candy with the wrapper on."
Brian Woodward, Niantic-Harristown High School, Niantic, Illinois

"What could be more pleasing than a society where nothing is wrong? That is the society we are developing. What was once considered wrong, now can be considered a mental problem or something you can not help because your parents weren't there for you. It is a pleasing idea, and that is why America is adopting it so rapidly. For a society not to blame individuals personally, it must accept everyone's personal definition of morals. If everyone has their own definition, then there are no morals, and if there are no morals then people can not live in peace."
Tom Moore, Niantic High School, Niantic, Illinois

If I could sum up my solution to this country's responsibility problem in one word, that word would be education."
Michael J. Pyle, Niantic High School, Niantic, Illinois



 


          

Back